We've already pretty well covered
the question of whether or (especially) not the character who's been ripping schwarzstern
, myself, and a few others off is, indeed, chaotic good. Here's the follow-up question: assuming the aforementioned player is playing a chaotic neutral character trying to pass herself off as chaotic good (and, of course, being neutral, thus being immune to the effects of detect evil
assuming that he really thinks he's accurately portraying a chaotic good alignment and further that the DM will not do anything about his misplaying of his character (for example, if he agrees), what would you suggest we do
Remember that our characters are neutral good, and as of this moment we haven't actually seen evidence of his treachery.